While the blog only has 3 "followers" so far, judging by my email inbox, others are "lurking" with their eyes, but not signing up. So I am encouraged at this new effort.
One email correspondent talked about how we can be more welcoming and comforting when we see someone near us in shul stand to recite the mourners Kaddish. It is her custom to notice who is saying Kaddish, and if it is someone she doesn't know, she politely asks (later on, after the service, or at Kiddush) for whom s/he is reciting Kaddish. If it's a recent death, she offers words of condolence; if it's a yahrzheit, she might ask more about the person. Of course, she listens carefully and follows the lead of the mourner, to see if s/he desires longer conversation, or just a brief explanation. And if the person is upset during Kaddish, she might move closer, or stand next to the person, or even just give a small touch on the arm in solidarity and quiet comfort.
It reminds me also that it's interesting that in our congregation (as in many Conservative synagogues) we invite non-mourners to be seated, and only mourners stand to recite the Kaddish. In many congregations (Orthodox, Reform, and some Conservative), everyone stands for the Kaddish (mourners recite it, while non-mourners simply respond appropriately).
In my own reading of halakhah (Jewish law), it is of course always appropriate for mourners to stand, but, for non-mourners, either is appropriate. It is a matter of personal or community custom. In a way, it seems the act of faith (and the required personal strength or even courage) in the act of reciting Kaddish is that much greater because the person stands while others are seated. And it means all of us know who is saying kaddish -- giving us the opportunity also to offer words of comfort, or ask the person more about why/for whom s/he is saying Kaddish.
On the other hand, I often wonder if mourners wouldn't appreciate the solidarity of having everyone stand with them. Is the loneliness of mourning magnified when one stands by oneself? As the "rabbi," I am always standing, so I'm curious about the experiences others have had.
Looking forward to your reflections, and will provide more of my own tomorrow...
Jacob
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I like the idea of showing solidarity with those who are mourning by standing with them. At a Shiva, everyone stands.
ReplyDeleteI think a shiva and an average shabbat service are very different. At a shiva, I believe it is important that everyone stands in support for those mourning. At a regular service, however, I believe that standing alone shows that you're separating yourself from the others around you signifying the importance of your personal recitation of the mourners kaddish.
ReplyDelete